• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
All Home Robotics

All Home Robotics

Reviews for the Smart Home

  • START HERE
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Mobile Menu Featured Image
How to Make an Ultimate Smart Home - Set Up a Smart Home Quickly
START HERE
Categories
  • Home
  • Vacs
  • Mops
  • Mowers
  • Climate
  • Security
  • Irrigation
  • Hubs
  • Lights
  • Pets
  • Other
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Vacs
    • Best Roomba Models
  • Mops
    • Best Robot Mops Ranked
  • Mowers
    • Best Robot Lawn Mowers Ranked
  • Climate
    • Best Smart Thermostats This Year
  • Security
    • Best Smart Home Security Systems
  • Irrigation
    • Best Smart Irrigation Systems
  • Hubs
    • Best Smart Hubs on the Market
  • Lights
    • The Best Smart Lighting Systems
  • Pets
    • Best Pet Cam Dispensers Guide
    • Best Automatic Pet Feeders Guide
  • Other
    • Drones

RainMachine vs. Rachio vs. Skydrop vs. Hydrawise Review – Who Wins The Smart Irrigation Battle?

Last updated: September 18, 2024 by Patrick Sinclair 1 Comment

In today’s world of technology, it seems almost anything is possible and the list of devices that help us run our lives more efficiently continues to expand. Technology has touched virtually every consumer market and the home and garden segment is no exception, particularly with smart sprinkler controllers.

Smart sprinkler controllers offer consumers a great opportunity to manage their lawn duties in a totally different way.

Using a smart controller allows you to connect to the controller within your home via Wi-Fi and remotely adjust a number of lawn irrigation settings. You can use the controller to set automatic controls for a totally maintenance free experience or you can manually adjust settings.

Additionally, some smart controllers can actually adjust settings based on the current or forecasted weather as well.

Bottom Line Up Front: Of all the smart sprinklers, I personally prefer the Rachio system available here. Rachio has…

  • The best Ease of Use
  • remote App Control
  • Most integrations with other smart home devices

2019 UPDATE: To read more about my top choices for 2019, check out this roundup guide.

This additional functionality offers a range of benefits for homeowners and commercial property owners alike. It means you can efficiently control when your irrigation system waters your lawn no matter where you are in the world, as long as you have a Wi-Fi connection. This saves a tremendous amount of energy and water over the long-term and results in a significant amount of cost savings for property owners.

Additionally, it allows the job of irrigating your lawn to be done in the most efficient manner possible based on current weather conditions as opposed to what your schedule allows. Of course, this often results in a much healthier and better-looking lawn as well by ensuring your grass gets the proper irrigation at the right times.

There are many different types of smart irrigation controllers available on the market. Many of them offer similar functionality but with many different features and specific advantages or disadvantages. Below are a few of the models that we think offers the best value to consumers. All of them are solid quality products but with slightly different features that may make one better than another for your individual needs.

RainMachine 8

The RainMachine 8 Smart Sprinkler Controller is a great option for individuals that are looking to take advantage of the convenience and cost savings a smart controller can offer. This controller works by monitoring and compiling information from several weather reporting sources to determine what the appropriate level of irrigation is for your lawn. It automatically adjusts not only the amount of water used but also the schedule of irrigation as well.

This provides you with a supremely efficient mechanism to handle the watering duties for your lawn based on actual current weather conditions as well as what the forecasted weather is in the coming days. The RainMachine 8 not only saves you money and adds a nice level of convenience to your life; it also helps produce a healthier and greener lawn.

It is compatible with Windows, Android and iOS phones or tablets and you can see a detailed analysis of your lawn irrigation from any internet capable device. The unit is EPA WaterSense Certified and it comes with a modern and sleek appearance that is attractive. It can control up to eight irrigation zones, although it can be expanded to twelve or sixteen by upgrading to a different model.

Rachio 2nd Generation

The Second Generation Rachio Smart Controller is specifically designed to capture and maximize cost savings as well as convenience. It has been given many mentions and awards by different publications and organizations in the industry as well. The unit is EPA WaterSense Certified and Rachio even took things a step further by SWAT testing the device with several independent testing agencies to ensure it provides a reliable consumer experience.

The second generation unit can manage up to sixteen different zones and it comes with a free app that is compatible with iOS and Android devices. The Rachio constantly monitors the weather services for the latest weather updates and current conditions and then adjusts the irrigation schedule for your lawn based on the information received.

One of the best features the Rachio offers is it is easy to install and setup even if you do not have any experience with this type of device. For a complete novice, it only takes about thirty minutes to swap your old controller with a new Rachio unit.

If you already have a home automation system the Rachio seamlessly integrates with many of them such as Alexa, Nexia, Control4 and Next, among others. The unit is built inside the USA and it is known as a quality device that provides reliable functionality.

Read here my full Rachio 3 Smart Sprinkler Controller Review!

Skydrop

The Skydrop Smart Sprinkler Controller (read my full review here!) can control eight zones but you can expand it all the way up to sixteen. It allows you to have separate settings for each individual sprinkler within your irrigation system so you can literally have completely different schedules for each zone.

It has an integrated cloud service to take advantage of up-to-date weather information and it can run completely independently without any input at all from the user, making its own watering schedules based on current information.

The Skydrop is one of the more attractive looking units on the market and has an interactive user interface that allows you to control all settings from the device itself. While accessing the unit controls via Wi-Fi from a phone or tablet is convenient, it is also nice to be able to use direct controls as well. A feature that sets the Skydrop apart from other units is its ability to limit water usage on particular days or weeks.

If you live in a place where the local government limits irrigation times then you can easily put these settings into the Skydrop and let it automatically handle everything.

The unit comes with a solid two-year warranty and its ease of use and simple setup will please many consumers.

Read my full comparison of Rachio vs Skydrop Smart Irrigation System here!

Hydrawise

Hydrawise (read my full review here!) is a well-known name in the smart sprinkler controller market and the Hydrawise Smart Controller offers consumers an excellent value for a very affordable price. It is capable of handling the irrigation duties for up to twelve zones and automatically adjusts the watering schedule and amounts based on current weather forecasts. It connects via Wi-Fi and is compatible with any iOS or Android based internet capable device.

Additionally, you can access the controller settings from any computer via the Hydrawise website so no matter where you are in the world, making adjustments is just a few clicks away. Not many smart sprinkler controllers offer manual controls but with the Hydrawise you can use manual adjustments or program the controller to handle all the work, it’s all up to you.

The controller is not weather resistant so if you are planning on mounting a unit outdoors that is exposed to the elements then this unit is not a good fit. You get almost all of its features free of charge simply by purchasing the unit but Hydrawise does offer an upgraded membership which is called the enthusiast plan. This unlocks several features that make ownership even more convenient such as the ability to see historical data that is relevant to your irrigation system and the ability to manage multiple controllers.

Product Comparison Chart:

Product RainMachine Rachio Skydrop Hydrawise
Smart Watering Auto Schedule Yes Yes Yes Yes
Upgraded Membership/Features No No No Yes
Android & iOS Yes Yes Yes Yes
Manual Settings Yes Yes Yes Yes
Zone Mgmt. 8 16 8 12
Weather Resistant N/A N/A N/A N/A
EPA WaterSense Certified Yes Yes Yes Yes

Final Thoughts

Each controller above offers its own small advantages or disadvantages to ownership.

However, choosing any of the models above will without question offer you additional convenience and allow you cost savings that simply wasn’t before.

All of these controllers are produced and offered by well-known names in the home and garden industry with years of quality products in their product lines.

If still in doubt… I’d go with the Rachio available here.

Related posts:

smart irrigation systemsThe Best Smart Irrigation Systems – Top Smart Sprinkler Controllers Green IQ smart hub reviewGreenIQ Smart Garden Hub Review – Ready for Market? The Spruce Irrigation Controller Review: Pros and Cons The Rachio 3 Smart Sprinkler Controller Review: All You Need to Know

Filed Under: Smart Garden

About Patrick Sinclair

Patrick Sinclair is a geek; make no mistake about that. He runs All Home Robotics in his spare time so he doesn’t have to think about his depressing cubicle and it gives him an excuse to buy expensive gadgets to review!

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Patricia says

    May 17, 2021 at 1:44 pm

    Hi Patrick,

    Just to let you know that the Upgraded Membership/Features in hydrawise aren’t a plus. If you have the free plan you cannot choose the best weather station for you and the weather updates only once a day and not before watering. If you pay around 70 dollars a year you can choose the best weather station and it will update before watering too. So the plans mean that the free plans only cut on the smartness of hydrawise and make it a nonsense that to use the programmer with it full capabilities you have to pay a fee…

    Reply
    • inno42 says

      September 12, 2021 at 2:14 pm

      Hi Patricia.

      Thank you for your comment.

      I understand that the paid plans might not be delivering enough value for the money. However, for me personally, the upgraded membership in Hydrawise was actually helpful.

      Nevertheless, I understand that it wouldn’t be the best option for everybody though.

      Thank you for sharing your opinion!

      Have a great day!

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Popular Guides

  • Best Robot Vacuum Cleaners
  • The Best Smart Garage Openers
  • The Best Smart Irrigation Systems
  • Best Smart Home Security Systems
  • The Best Smart Thermostats

Popular Drones Articles

  • Blade 350 QX3 Review
  • The Top 7 Racing Drones
  • Top 3 Best Camera Drones

Popular Health Gadgets Articles

  • Samsung Gear Fit vs. Fitbit Charge: Which is Best?
  • Fitbit Blaze vs Fitbit Versa: Which One Will You Like More?
  • Fitbit Blaze vs Fitbit Charge: Which One Should You Buy?

Popular Home Climate Articles

  • Top WiFi Thermostats That Don’t Need a C-Wire
  • The Top 3 Sensibo Alternatives Worth the Money in 2021
  • Which One Works Best? Ecobee3 vs. Emerson Sensi Smart Thermostat

Popular Home Security Articles

  • The Best Z-Wave Compatible Doorbells You’ll Want to Install Now!
  • Wyze vs. Nest Cam Compared: Which Security Camera Should You Buy?
  • One IS Better: Schlage Connect vs Sense in 2021

Popular Hoverboards Articles

  • SwagTron T1 vs T5 – Which SwagTron is a Better Value?
  • The Definitive Swagtron T5 Review – Does it Hold Up?
  • The Ultimate Swagtron T6 Off-Road Smart Board Review

Popular Kids Articles

  • The Best Elegoo Tutorials to Get You Started
  • Elegoo vs Arduino: Which Will Your Kids Love Most?
  • Ozobot Bit vs. Ozobot Evo -Which is Best for Your Kids?

Popular Kitchen Gadgets Articles

  • Tovala Smart Oven Review: Does it Live Up to the Hype?
  • Review: Checking Out the iGrill 2 Smart Thermometer
  • Cinder Precision Smart Grill Review – The Ultimate Steak?

Popular Articles

  • Believe it or Not: These Plex Alternatives Are Actually Better!
  • The Best Elgato Stream Deck Alternatives
  • The Best Tesla Powerwall Alternatives You Need to Know About!

Popular Pool Articles

  • Aquabot vs Dolphin: Which is the Best Robot Pool Cleaner?
  • Aquabot Breeze XLS Review – Is This Pool Robot Worth the Money?
  • Aquabot X4 Review – Should You Buy It?

Popular Robot Lawn Mowers Articles

  • Honda Miimo vs Husqvarna Automower: The Full Comparison
  • The McCulloch ROB 1000 Review: Is It a Good Buy?
  • The Husqvarna Automower 220 AC Review: Does it Live Up to the Promises?

Popular Robot Mops Articles

  • Braava m6 vs. Braava Jet 240: Which One Is Perfect for You?
  • The Best Robot Mops for 2021: Beware of the Knock Offs!
  • Scooba 450 vs Braava 380t – What are the Main Differences?

Popular Robot Vacuums Articles

  • Ecovacs Deebot vs iRobot Roomba – Which one Is Better? [2021 Review]
  • Roomba i7 vs. s9: Which is the Best iRobot Vac [2021 Review]
  • Roomba Error Codes – Troubleshooting Your Roomba

Popular Routeurs Articles

  • Orbi vs Nighthawk – Which Wi-Fi System to Buy in 2021?
  • Best Routers for Smart Security Cameras
  • My Top 3 Fingbox Alternatives That You’ll Love

Popular Smart Audio Articles

  • The Best Speakers for Chromecast Audio
  • Which Smart Home Speaker is Best? Amazon Tap vs Echo
  • Kohler Moxie Review – Checking Out This Smart Showerhead

Popular Smart Garden Articles

  • Rain Bird vs. Rachio Smart Sprinkler Systems: Which is Best?
  • The Full Click and Grow vs. AeroGarden Comparison Review
  • Hydrawise Smart Irrigation Controller Review – Smart Enough?

Popular Smart Home Articles

  • The Best Home Automation Ideas for 2021
  • How to Make an Ultimate Smart Home – Set Up a Smart Home Quickly!
  • 25 Best Smart Home Automation Blogs [2021 Awards]

Popular Smart Hubs Articles

  • One IS Better: Wink vs Smarthings in 2021
  • Samsung SmartThings Hub vs Logitech Harmony Hub: Which is Best?
  • Everything You Need to Know About The Ezlo Smart Home Z-Wave Hub

Popular Smart Lighting Articles

  • The Best Automatic Porch Light Timers Out There!
  • Leviton vs. Lutron Smart Home System: Which Is Best For You?
  • The Best Smart Lighting Systems for 2021

Popular Smart Money Saving Articles

  • Save Money on Water! Here’s the Full LeakSMART Review
  • Amphiro A1 Self Monitoring Water & Energy Smart Meter Review
  • Keep Track of Your Home Energy Consumption: The Curb Home Energy Review

Popular Smart Pet Articles

  • My Litter Robot vs Cat Genie Comparison – Which is the Best Litter Robot?
  • The Best Smart Dog Doors That You’ll Love
  • The Best Smart Pet Cameras and Dispensers for 2020

Popular Smart Remotes Articles

  • Logitech Harmony 650 vs 700: Which Universal Remote Will You Love?
  • The Ultimate List of the Best Smart Remote Options for 2020
  • A Blumoo Smart Remote Review – Pros and Cons

Popular Streaming Articles

  • AirPlay vs. Chromecast: Which Is Best For You?
  • Don’t Get Conned: Sling vs Roku in 2020 (Hint: One IS Better)
  • Fire TV Cube vs FireStick: Which is Best for Streaming?

Popular Telepresence Robots Articles

  • Best Telepresence Robots for 2021: Don’t Buy One of the Duds!
  • The Best Alternatives to Double Robotics Telepresence Robots
  • Kubi Classic Review: Is This the Telepresence Robot for You?

Popular Trackers Articles

  • TrackR vs Tile: Which Should You Choose in 2021?
  • TrackR Bravo vs TrackR Pixel – Find Your Lost Things Quickly!
  • TrackR vs Chipolo Compared – Stop Losing Your Keys!

Popular TV Articles

  • Best Wireless Keyboard for Samsung Smart TVs [Reviewed 2021]
  • Best Smart TVs Under $300 for 2020 That Actually Look Great
  • The Best Keyboards for Smart TVs: What to Consider

Popular VOIP Articles

  • The Best Alternatives to Ooma Phone Service You Need to Know
  • Ooma Telo vs Obihai Obi200 VoIP Phone Adapter: Which One Works Best?
  • What are the Best Ooma Telo Alternatives?

Popular VR Articles

  • Valve Index vs Oculus Rift S – Which Will You Love More?
  • Oculus Rift vs Google Cardboard, Which is the Better VR Experience?
  • The VR Experience Showdown: Samsung Gear VR vs Oculus Rift

Footer

Resources

  • Terms of Use
  • Affiliate Disclosure
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy (EU)

Popular Guides

  • Best Robot Vacuum Cleaners
  • The Best Smart Garage Openers
  • The Best Smart Irrigation Systems
  • Best Smart Home Security Systems
  • The Best Smart Thermostats

All Home Robotics – A BTK21 Web AG Company

Baarermattstrasse 8c,
Baar 6340, Zug, Switzerland
Email Support: [email protected]

Allhomerobotics.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. Amazon, the Amazon logo, AmazonSupply, and the AmazonSupply logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. As an Amazon Associate we earn affiliate commissions from qualifying purchases.


Copyright © 2021 - All Home Robotics. All rights reserved.

Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
  • Manage options
  • Manage services
  • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
  • Read more about these purposes
View preferences
  • {title}
  • {title}
  • {title}